Shelter Island, NY Real Estate

Shelter Island NY Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







Shelter Island NY Real Estate Stats

Average Price in Shelter Island: $1,744,786  County Average: $797,432

Average Taxes in Shelter Island: $8,052  County Average: $11,896

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in Shelter Island: $643  County Average: $281

Average Walkscore in Shelter Island: 10  County Average: 27

Average Year Built in Shelter Island: 1981  County Average: 1975

Average Days on Website in Shelter Island: 169  County Average: 113

Shelter Island NY Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhoods in Shelter Island NY

Shelter Island

Areas in Shelter Island NY

Center Congdon Creek West Neck Bay Area

Most Popular Listing

Popular Shelter Island Real Estate

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive Shelter Island Real Estate

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap Shelter Island Real Estate

Listings in Shelter Island

Charming shingle beach house with dock on west neck bay with 255' of waterfront, beautiful sunset views, 4 bedroom, 3...

Step back in time to this quaint, beautifully restored 3br farmhouse...

110 ft beach front cape,3 bd, 2 bath. enjoy sunrise overlooking Shelter Island and greenport shores. anchor a 30ft boat on 150lb mushroom anchor. furnished house...

Located in a desirable area of Shelter Island known as hay beach, this new traditional home is ready for its new owner...

a 68-acre park with 2,800 feet of shoreline that faces Shelter Island sound, a spectacular location!...


Charming & sophisticated, this newly constructed farmhouse is simply perfect...

situated on 12+ acres with over 1200' on the bay. majestic views to Shelter Island and beyond. minutes from golf, shopping, restaurants and galleries of greenport. private bay beach, marina, pool, tennis, and clubhouse with fit...

Renovated expanded cape, annual taxes approx $5760...

In the historic village of dering harbor, this 3.1 acre property is down a scenic, wooded, private lane...

water frontage on coveted & protected gull pond. open views of Shelter Island & greenport harbor. deep water access from gull pond to orient bay. a bea...

Just shy of an acre lot, on beautiful Shelter Island...

Nd stunning views of orient harbor, bug light and Shelter Island. moor your boat in the bay; kayak, swim, fish or chill on the decks and porches. base...

This well thought out property is designed for a 3,868 square feet home with 2 master suites and 3 additional bedrooms with bathrooms, the kitchen is suited for any cook...

Scenic & updated w/open vaulted living area, gas fireplace, dining & eat in kitchen w/gracious french doors to dining deck...

Private drive to large treed property on lake, bucolic waterfront setting, newly renovated incredible modern beach cottage, 3 waterside bedrooms (including spacious master suite) with doors to waterfront patio, lawn and waterside deck...

close to transportation, restaurants, shops, brewery, harbor, marina and Shelter Island ferry. enjoy beaches and sunsets....

mooring for small boat. 2nd floor deck with views of Shelter Island, orient, bug lighthouse....

imagine sitting on your front porch watching the sunset over the bay and having Shelter Island's beautiful shell beach just a stone's throw away....

Stunning, unobstructed views of peconic bay and Shelter Island...

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

La Rosa Realty, New York
1979 Marcus Avenue Suite 210
Lake Success, NY